We've tightened what earns a Pursue. A home now needs a published valuation, a strategy that still makes money after real running costs and lender stress tests, and no listing problems that would stop a mortgage. You'll see fewer Pursues, and each one has been checked harder.
See how verdicts work3-bedroom semi-detached house · CA11 9HR
For saleListed 4 days
Opportunity summary
See Archie’s verdict, returns by strategy and what to check before viewing.
About
Currently used as a successful holiday letting business and ideal as a grand family home, Rutherford House is a handsome Grade 2 listed semi detached home offering spacious and characterful accommodation over three floors comprising; Porch, Hallway, Living Room, Dining Room, Kitchen, Bathroom with rolltop bath, three Double Bedrooms and a Shower Room.
Outside there is a Forecourt Garden with Off Road Parking Space and an Enclosed Rear Garden, both offering a good degree of privacy.
There is also an Outhouse/Workshop and an external access to an under-croft store.
Rutherford House is in a convenient location, on the northern side of town, just a 10 minute walk from Penrith town centre and a 5 minute walk from the Thacka Beck Nature Reserve, Location - From the centre of Penrith, head up Castlegate, cross over the 2 mini roundabouts and drive down Brunswick Road.
Follow around the left hand bend, keep in the left hand lane and then fork left into Stricklandgate.
Cross over the mini roundabout and then turn left into Robinson Street, Rutherford House is on the right.
The what3words position is; solves.armrests.plenty Amenities - Penrith is a popular market town on the edge of the Lake District National Park, having excellent transport links through the M6, A66, A6 and the main West coast railway line.
There is a population of around 17,000 people and facilities include: infant, junior and secondary schools. There are 5 supermarkets and a good range of locally owned and national high street shops.
Leisure facilities include: a leisure centre with; swimming pool, climbing wall, indoor bowling, badminton courts and a fitness centre as well as; golf, rugby and cricket clubs.
There is also a 3 screen cinema and Penrith Playhouse.
Penrith is known as the Gateway to the North Lakes and is conveniently situated for Ullswater and access to the fells as well as the beautiful Eden Valley, benefiting from the superb outdoor recreation opportunities.
Services - Mains water, drainage, gas and electricity are connected to the property. Tenure - The property is freehold. The property is currently registered for Business Rates.
The rateable value from April 2026 is £2,700 and under the small business relief the amount payable is nil.
Anti Money Laundering Requirements - In line with The Money Laundering, Terrorist Financing and Transfer of Funds (information on the Payer) Regulations 2017, as a regulated profession, we are duty bound to carry out due diligence on all of our clients to confirm their identity.
Rather than traditional methods in which you would have to produce multiple utility bills and a photographic ID we use an electronic verification system.
This system allows us to verify you from basic details using electronic data, however it is not a credit check of any kind so will have no effect on you or your credit history.
To do so the Credit Referencing Agencies may check the details you supply against any particulars on any database (public or otherwise) to which they have access.
They may also use your details in the future to assist other companies for verification purposes. A record of the search will be retained.
A fee of (£24 inc VAT) per purchaser will be charged to cover the costs associated with fulfilling our obligations under the act.
A link will be sent to your mobile to enable you to make the payment and thereafter the biometric check.
Viewing - STRICTLY BY APPOINTMENT WITH WILKES-GREEN + HILL Accommodation - Entrance - A panel door with patterned, leaded glass insets, opens to the; Porch - Having double glazed windows to two sides, tiled flooring and a multi pane glazed door to the; Hall - 4.11m x 1.91m (13'6 x 6'3) - Having stripped floorboards, a single radiator, a telecoms point and a floor cupboard housing the electric meter and MCB consumer unit.
Stripped and polished panel doors lead off. Living Room - 4.85m x 4.47m (15'11 x 14'8) - A multi fuel stove is set on a natural stone hearth and to one wall is a large arched furniture recess.
There is picture rail around the room, original plaster coving and a central ceiling rose.
The floorboards are polished and there is a double radiator, a TV aerial point and a double glazed window to the front.
Dining Room - 4.24m x 4.17m (13'11 x 13'8) - An attractive cast iron feature fireplace is set on a quarry tile hearth with a shelved recess and floor cupboard to one side.
There is a picture rail around the room, plaster coving to the ceiling, and the floorboards are polished. Stairs lead to the first floor with painted handrails and spindles and a store cupboard below.
There is a double radiator and a double glazed window faces to the rear.
Kitchen - 3.18m x 3.35m (10'5 x 11') - Fitted with painted units and a solid wood worksurface incorporating a ceramic Belfast sink with carved drainer and mixer tap.
There is a built-in electric oven and induction hob with a tiled splashback and a stainless steel cooker hood, plumbing in one of the units for a washing machine and space for a dishwasher.
A wall cupboard houses, a Worcester gas fired condensing combi boiler, providing the hot water and central heating. A window overlooks the rear garden and a part glazed stable door opens to the side.
Bathroom - 4.04m x 1.22m (13'3 x 4') - Fitted with a traditional toilet, pedestal wash basin and a rolltop clawfoot bath with patterned tiling to one side.
The flooring is parquet and there is a single radiator, an extractor fan and a window.
First Floor - Landing - Panel doors open to bedrooms one and two, the shower room and the stairs leading to the attic.
Bedroom One - 3.51m x 4.19m (11'6 x 13'9) - Having a picture rail around, plaster coving to three sides, polished floorboards, a double radiator and a double glazed window to the front with a view across Penrith to the Lakeland Fells around Ullswater.
Bedroom Two - 4.57m x 3.56m max (15' x 11'8 max) - A plank door opens to a walk-in wardrobe with hanging and shelf storage space.
There is a picture rail and dado rail around the room, a single radiator and a window to the rear looking out across the surrounding gardens.
Shower Room - 1.22m x 2.77m (4' x 9'1) - Fitted with a wall mounted wash basin, a toilet and a shower enclosure with marine board to three sides and an electric shower over.
There is a chrome heated towel rail and an extractor fan. Second Floor - The stairs rise into; Bedroom Three - 4.72m x 4.17m (15'6 x 13'8) - Having a double radiator and a double glazed window.
A ceiling trap gives access to the roof space and low doors give access to eaves storage to the front and rear.
Outside - To the front of Rutherford house is a forecourt garden to grass with a stonewall to the roadside and mature shrubs giving privacy. A block paved driveway provides off road parking.
A wooden gate from the parking area opens to a path leading to the rear garden.
The rear garden is laid to grass with low-level shrub borders to two sides, a stone paved seating area and a stonewall and high wood fence around.
Steps from the garden lead down to a door giving access to an undercroft storage area, with limited headroom.
To the side of the house is a block and stone built; Outhouse - 2.41m x 1.65m (7'11 x 5'5) - With light and power points.
Referal Fees - WGH work with the following provider for arrangement of mortgage & other products/insurances, however you are under no obligation to use their services and may wish to compare them against other providers.
Should you choose to utilise them WGH will receive a referral fee : Fisher Financial, Carlisle The Right Advice (Bulman Pollard) Carlisle Average referral fee earned in 2024 was £253.00
Value & comps
No previous sales on record.
Returns
Set an offer; the calculator follows it.
We're still gathering serviced-accommodation data for this area.
Archie refurb estimate: a Pro feature
0.0% below asking
This is not financial or investment advice. Prop AI Deals is not authorised by the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) to provide investment advice.
All investment calculators, property analyses, and AI-generated insights are for informational purposes only. Property investment carries risk and may result in financial loss. All calculations should be independently verified and you should consult with FCA-authorised financial advisers before making any investment decisions.
Past performance does not guarantee future results. Tax implications vary by individual circumstances.
Deal
Properties like this can earn 2–3x BTL yields when converted to HMO, with retrofit costs around £10k/room. Sign in to see the full tier, yield projection, and cost breakdown.
Commercial properties like this can earn 30-50% higher yields when converted to residential under Class MA / Q / P / PA, with prior approval costing ~GBP 96/unit. Sign in to see the recommended route, yield uplift, and cost breakdown.
BRRR-suited properties can recycle 80-100% of investor capital on refi, leaving a high-yielding rental with most of the money out. Sign in to see the refurb cost stack, ARV projection, and refinance maths.
Detached + large garden = sub-division play. Pro tier unlocks the tier badge, plot size, uplift estimate, and regional land benchmark.
Short-lease flats trade at deep discount, but extending under the 1993 Act often costs far less than the discount. Pro tier unlocks the tier badge, premium breakdown, long-lease ARV and arbitrage maths.
See projected short-stay revenue vs a vanilla BTL for this property.
See real sub-let margins (HMO room rates & SA nightly rates) vs the landlord rent.
Area
Agent & docs

FAQ
About Robinson Street, Penrith
Explore nearby