We've tightened what earns a Pursue. A home now needs a published valuation, a strategy that still makes money after real running costs and lender stress tests, and no listing problems that would stop a mortgage. You'll see fewer Pursues, and each one has been checked harder.
See how verdicts work6-bedroom detached house · EH10 6HQ
For saleReduced £105k (−9.5%) on 27 OctListed 34 days
Opportunity summary
See Archie’s verdict, returns by strategy and what to check before viewing.
About
5 Comiston Rise offers a substantial detached family home extending to over 3,700 sq ft, set within the highly desirable Comiston area of Edinburgh's south side.
Boasting a flexible five to six-bedroom layout, extensive private gardens, a secure driveway and far-reaching views across Edinburgh and beyond, this impressive property presents a rare opportunity to acquire a significant family home with outstanding potential in one of the city's most sought-after residential locations.
Arranged over three levels, the property is entered via an impressive ground-floor vestibule that creates a welcoming first impression.
To the rear, the generously proportioned sitting room provides an ideal space for both everyday family life and entertaining, with direct access to a large south-facing terrace overlooking the gardens.
Adjacent to the sitting room is a formal dining room, ideal for family meals and larger gatherings.
The well-appointed kitchen offers excellent storage and worktop space and is complemented by a separate utility room.
The ground-floor accommodation is completed by a generous fifth bedroom, versatile family snug or sixth bedroom, a gym and a spacious family bathroom.
The first floor centres around a bright central landing providing access to all rooms and the upper floor.
The impressive principal bedroom is a standard out feature, which is enhanced by a private dressing room and en-suite bathroom.
This level also hosts three further double bedrooms, two of which benefit from en-suite facilities, creating excellent accommodation for larger families and visiting guests alike.
The second floor is home to a spacious games room and a separate study.
These adaptable rooms offer a variety of potential uses, including home working, hobbies, recreation, or additional guest accommodation, depending on individual requirements.
Externally, the property is set within substantial private gardens that wrap around the house, providing an excellent outdoor environment for family life.
The large south-facing terrace extends directly from the sitting room and enjoys wonderful views towards the Pentland Hills and beyond.
The outdoor accommodation is further enhanced by a secure driveway, offering generous off-street parking for multiple vehicles.
Summary of Accommodation Ground Floor: Vestibule, Hall, Sitting Room, Dining Room, Kitchen, Utility, Fifth Bedroom, Snug/Sixth Bedroom, Gym, Bathroom First Floor: Principal Bedroom with Dressing Room and Ensuite, Two Bedrooms with Ensuites, Fourth Bedroom Second Floor: Spacious Games Room, Study Externally: Large Wrapped Around Gardens, South Facing Terrace, Secure Driveway Location Comiston is a highly sought-after residential district situated to the south of Edinburgh's city centre, renowned for its leafy surroundings, excellent schooling and family-friendly atmosphere.
The area offers a superb range of local amenities, including independent cafés, restaurants, supermarkets and convenience stores, while nearby Morningside provides an even wider selection of boutique shopping and leisure facilities.
Surrounded by beautiful green spaces including the Pentland Hills, Braid Hills and the Hermitage of Braid, Comiston offers an outstanding balance of outdoor lifestyle and city convenience, with excellent public transport links providing swift access to the city centre and beyond.
EPC: C Council Tax: G Tenure: Freehold Viewing by appointment via Rettie&Co EPC Rating: C Council Tax Band: G
Value & comps
Land Registry doesn’t cover Scotland or Northern Ireland, so previous sales may not be on record.
Returns
Set an offer; the calculator follows it.
Short-let restrictions apply
We're still gathering serviced-accommodation data for this area.
Archie refurb estimate: a Pro feature
0.0% below asking
This is not financial or investment advice. Prop AI Deals is not authorised by the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) to provide investment advice.
All investment calculators, property analyses, and AI-generated insights are for informational purposes only. Property investment carries risk and may result in financial loss. All calculations should be independently verified and you should consult with FCA-authorised financial advisers before making any investment decisions.
Past performance does not guarantee future results. Tax implications vary by individual circumstances.
Deal
Properties like this can earn 2–3x BTL yields when converted to HMO, with retrofit costs around £10k/room. Sign in to see the full tier, yield projection, and cost breakdown.
Commercial properties like this can earn 30-50% higher yields when converted to residential under Class MA / Q / P / PA, with prior approval costing ~GBP 96/unit. Sign in to see the recommended route, yield uplift, and cost breakdown.
BRRR-suited properties can recycle 80-100% of investor capital on refi, leaving a high-yielding rental with most of the money out. Sign in to see the refurb cost stack, ARV projection, and refinance maths.
Detached + large garden = sub-division play. Pro tier unlocks the tier badge, plot size, uplift estimate, and regional land benchmark.
Short-lease flats trade at deep discount, but extending under the 1993 Act often costs far less than the discount. Pro tier unlocks the tier badge, premium breakdown, long-lease ARV and arbitrage maths.
See projected short-stay revenue vs a vanilla BTL for this property.
See real sub-let margins (HMO room rates & SA nightly rates) vs the landlord rent.
Area
Agent & docs

FAQ
About 5, Comiston Rise, Comiston, Edinburgh
Explore nearby